I’ve been doing this for 35 years. More than 100 organisations. I’ve sat in boardrooms, lunchrooms, site sheds, and more Zoom calls that should have been emails than I care to count.
I’ve seen leadership that made me want to stand on my chair and cheer.
And I’ve seen leadership that made me want to crawl under the boardroom table, pull the tablecloth down and live there.
Here’s what nobody tells you: most bad leaders aren’t bad people. They’re unaware. Untrained. Unchecked. They got promoted because they were brilliant at the job, then got handed a team and a “good luck with that.” Some work out the people part. Plenty never do. And their teams pay for it.
The good news? Every single thing on this list is fixable. The catch? You have to be brave enough to look in the mirror first. Not at your boss. Not at that one person in finance. You.
So grab a coffee (or a wine, no judgement here, it’s been a year), and let’s get honest.
1. Making it all about them (the ego trip)
Oh, the ego. The number one leadership killer I see, hands down. And it’s a master of disguise.
What it looks like:
- Needing to be the smartest person in every room, every time
- Hogging the airtime and talking over people (yes, we all notice)
- “I” this, “I” that, and barely a “we” in sight
- Surrounding yourself with yes-people because disagreement feels like a personal attack
- Taking the team’s idea upstairs and presenting it as your own. Bold. Very bold.
Why it hurts: When the leader’s ego sucks up all the oxygen, everyone else stops breathing. People stop speaking up. They stop sharing ideas. They stop telling you the truth. And a leader who can’t hear the truth is flying blind, with a full plane behind them.
Do this instead:
- Speak last. In your next meeting, sit on your opinion until everyone else has had their say. It’ll feel like torture. Do it anyway, then watch what happens.
- Count your “I”s. Reread your last five emails. Who’s the main character?
- Ask the magic question: “What am I missing?” Then zip it and actually listen.
- Give credit loudly and specifically. Not “great job team”. Try “Priya’s analysis is the reason we caught this.” Then watch Priya grow two inches.
Confidence is quiet. Ego is loud. Be the quiet one.
2. Thinking they’ve “arrived” (and stopping their own growth)
This one makes my eye twitch. “I’ve been doing this for 20 years, I don’t need a course.” The last leadership book they read came out around the GFC. Never had a coach. Never asked for feedback. Genuinely believes the title on the door means they’ve graduated.
Oh, darling. The title is the starting line, not the finish line.
Why it hurts: Work has changed more in the last five years than in the twenty before it. Hybrid teams. AI. Four generations in one office. Burnout through the roof. If you’re still leading like it’s 2015, you’re not leading. You’re reminiscing.
And here’s the kicker: your team can see it. The minute you stop growing, you quietly give everyone else permission to stop too.
Do this instead:
- Ask for feedback every quarter. Keep it simple: “What’s one thing I should start doing, and one thing I should stop?” Brace yourself. Then say thank you.
- Get a coach or mentor. Every elite athlete has a coach. You really think you’re the exception?
- Block an hour a week for learning. Put it in your calendar and guard it like a client meeting. Read, listen, reflect.
- Find a reverse mentor. Someone younger or newer who’ll show you what you can’t see from your corner office (or your kitchen table).
- Do the inner work. Self-awareness sits underneath every great leader I’ve ever met. Know your triggers, your blind spots and your patterns. Yes, all of them.
The best leaders I know are the hungriest learners in the building. Every. Single. Time.
3. Forgetting the team exists
Some leaders are absolute pros at managing up. Polished for the board. Lightning fast for the CEO. Across every strategy deck. And their team? Their team hasn’t had a one-on-one since March.
What it looks like:
- Cancelling one-on-ones whenever something “more important” comes up (which is always, isn’t it?)
- No idea what motivates each person, where they want to go, or what’s happening in their life
- Calling people “resources” and “headcount”. They’re humans. With names.
- Only turning up when something’s gone wrong
Why it hurts: People don’t leave companies, they leave leaders. You’ve heard it a hundred times because it’s true. Your job isn’t to be the hero. It’s to make your people the heroes.
Do this instead:
- Protect one-on-ones like board meetings. Move them if you must. Never just cancel.
- Know three things about every person: what drives them, where they want to go, and what’s getting in their way.
- Ask “What do you need from me?” often. Then actually deliver it.
- Have real career conversations at least twice a year. Not performance reviews. Conversations about them, their hopes, their next move.
- Catch people doing things right. Recognition costs nothing and pays back tenfold.
If your team only hears from you when there’s a problem, you’re not a leader. You’re a smoke alarm. And nobody loves the smoke alarm.
4. Dodging the hard conversations
I have watched entire teams quietly fall apart because one leader couldn’t bring themselves to have one difficult conversation. One.
What it looks like:
- Hoping it’ll “sort itself out” (spoiler: it never, ever does)
- A feedback sandwich with so much bread nobody can find the filling
- Shuffling the problem person off to another team. Congratulations, you’ve just regifted a problem.
- Letting poor behaviour slide because “they’re having a tough time” or “but they’re so good at their job”
Why it hurts: Every time you dodge a hard conversation, your best people notice. They’re the ones picking up the slack, and they’re the ones who’ll walk out first. Avoidance isn’t kindness. It’s cowardice in a nice cardigan.
As Brené Brown says, clear is kind. Unclear is unkind.
Do this instead:
- Use the 48-hour rule. If it needs saying, say it within two days. Problems are like laundry. Leave them and they pile up and start to smell.
- Keep it simple. What I saw. The impact it had. What I need. What support you need from me.
- Lead with curiosity, not accusation. “Help me understand what’s happening” opens doors. “Why did you…” slams them shut.
- Practise. Courageous conversations are a skill, not a personality trait. Nobody’s born good at them. You get better with reps.
5. Keeping the glory and passing the blame
Credit floats up. Blame rolls down. We’ve all worked for this leader, and some of us still have the scars to prove it.
Why it hurts: Nothing kills trust faster. The moment your team watches you throw someone under the bus, it’s over. They’ll never fully trust you again. And they’ll stop taking risks, because why on earth would they?
Do this instead:
- Adopt this mantra: “Wins are yours. Misses are mine.”
- Own your mistakes out loud. “I got that wrong, and here’s what I’m doing about it” might be the most powerful sentence a leader can say. It won’t make you look weak. It makes you look human.
- Back your people in public. Coach them in private. Never the other way around.
6. Micromanaging (a control freak in a leadership costume)
You hired smart people. Then you told them exactly how to do everything, cc’d yourself on every email, and rewrote their work at 10pm with a glass of shiraz.
Why it hurts: Micromanagement shouts one message, loud and clear: I don’t trust you. It crushes confidence, kills initiative, and burns you out at the same time. Nobody wins. Not them, not you, not the business.
Do this instead:
- Agree on the what and the when. Let go of the how.
- Check in, don’t check up. Set touchpoints upfront so you’re not hovering like a helicopter parent at the school sports carnival.
- Ask yourself: “What’s the worst that happens if I let this go?” It’s usually far less dramatic than the movie playing in your head.
- Remember: if you’re doing your team’s job, who on earth is doing yours?
7. Weather-report leadership
You know the one. The team checks the leader’s face before they check their inbox. Sunny? Great day. Storm clouds? Everyone’s tiptoeing on eggshells and nobody’s asking for a thing.
Why it hurts: Unpredictability breeds fear, and fear shuts down the thinking part of the brain. Your team ends up spending all their energy managing your moods instead of doing great work. That’s a very expensive way to run a business.
Do this instead:
- Name your state. “I’m a bit flat today, it’s not about you” takes ten seconds and saves hours of anxious overthinking.
- Pause before you react. Breathe. Count to five. Draft the email, then send it tomorrow.
- Know your triggers. Self-awareness again (told you it’d come back, see point 2).
- Consistency beats charisma. Every day of the week, and twice on Mondays.
8. Saying one thing and doing another
The values are on the wall in a lovely font. Respect. Integrity. Wellbeing. And then the leader sends emails at 11pm, rolls their eyes in meetings, and breaks the promises they made last week. Hmm.
Why it hurts: Your team doesn’t listen to what you say. They watch what you do. Every gap between your words and your actions chips away at your credibility, one tiny crack at a time. And cracks spread.
Do this instead:
- Audit yourself. Look at your calendar and your behaviour this week. Would a stranger be able to guess your values from them?
- Keep the small promises. “I’ll get back to you Friday” matters. Big trust is built from small promises kept.
- If you preach wellbeing, live it. Take your leave. Log off. Schedule send is your new best friend.
9. Tolerating the brilliant jerk
They smash every target. They’re also rude, dismissive, and leaving a trail of bruised people behind them. And the leader? Looking the other way, because the numbers are great.
Why it hurts: What you tolerate, you endorse. Full stop. Every time you let a high performer behave badly, you’re telling the whole team exactly what this culture values. Spoiler: it isn’t them.
Do this instead:
- Make performance about the what and the how. Results achieved by trampling people aren’t results. They’re debt, and the interest is brutal.
- Address behaviour regardless of output. One standard. For everyone.
- Do the maths. One brilliant jerk can cost you three great people. That’s a terrible trade.
10. Leaving people in the dark
Information is power, and some leaders hoard it like a dragon sitting on a pile of gold. Change gets dropped at the last minute. Decisions appear out of thin air. The team hears about the restructure from the rumour mill (or the car park).
Why it hurts: When people don’t know what’s going on, they fill the gap with the worst possible story. Anxiety goes up, productivity goes down, and your best people quietly start polishing their LinkedIn profiles.
Do this instead:
- Share the why, not just the what. People can handle almost anything when they understand the reason.
- Over-communicate during change. Then communicate some more. Then once more for the people at the back.
- When you don’t have all the answers, use this script: “Here’s what I know. Here’s what I don’t know yet. Here’s when I’ll know more.”
11. Leading on empty
This one’s personal. I know it from the inside, because I lived it. I was strong for too long.
The leader who never takes leave. Who wears exhaustion like a badge of honour. Who’s always “fine”, always on, always carrying everything for everyone. We love to celebrate this leader. We really shouldn’t.
I was that leader. A sole parent building a business from scratch, answering every “How are you?” with “Fine!” Spoiler: I wasn’t fine.
Why it hurts: You can’t pour from an empty cup, and your team is watching how you treat yourself. Run yourself into the ground and you’re quietly teaching them that’s what success looks like. Burnt-out leaders make poorer decisions, have shorter fuses, and eventually, they break. Trust me on this one.
Do this instead:
- Model boundaries out loud. “I’m offline after 6 tonight” gives your whole team permission to do the same.
- Take your leave. All of it. The business will survive. And if it won’t, that’s a leadership problem worth fixing.
- Ask for help. Being strong doesn’t mean doing it alone. It means knowing when not to.
- Look after the basics. Sleep, movement, and people who fill your cup. They’re not optional extras. They’re leadership fuel.
The common thread
Look back over that list. Ego. No growth. Ignoring the team. Avoiding conflict. Blame. Control. Moodiness. Hypocrisy. Tolerating bad behaviour. Secrecy. Burnout.
Almost every single one comes down to two things: a lack of self-awareness and a lack of courage.
The courage to look at yourself honestly. To have the conversation. To let go. To admit you got it wrong. To put your people first, even when it’s harder. Especially when it’s harder.
Leadership isn’t a position. It’s a privilege. And every single day, you get to decide whether you’re earning it.
Your Human Leader Index: where are you really at?
Every one of those eleven sins is a symptom. The cause? Almost always a part of the leader that’s gone missing under pressure.
That’s exactly why I built the Human Leader Model. Great leadership isn’t a job title or a list of competencies. It’s a whole human, showing up whole. Six zones, with attitude running like a current through every one of them.
And here’s what I’ve seen over and over again: under pressure, leadership breaks from the top down. Lose your head, and your heart goes next. Lose your heart, and your judgement gets cloudy. Before long your spine’s gone soft, your hands have stopped serving, and the footprint you leave behind is one nobody wants to follow.
So let’s map those sins back to where they really live:
- Regulated Head (staying in charge of your own brain): weather-report leadership, leading on empty
- Kind Heart (seeing people as full human beings): forgetting the team exists, leaving people in the dark
- Wise Gut (deciding well before you have all the facts): micromanaging, thinking you’ve arrived
- Brave Spine (who you are when nobody’s watching): dodging hard conversations, passing the blame, saying one thing and doing another, tolerating the brilliant jerk
- The Hands (service, or what you actually do with it all): making it all about you instead of serving the people you lead
- Attitude (the current through every zone): ego, and the belief you’ve got nothing left to learn
- The Footprint (what the other five leave behind): the culture, the trust, the people who stayed and the people who left. Every sin above turns up here eventually.
Take the Human Leader Index (quick self-check)
Rate yourself from 1 (rarely) to 5 (always) on each statement. Be brutally honest. Nobody’s watching, and honestly, that’s the whole point.
1. Regulated Head
- Under pressure, I pause before I react.
- My team would say I’m the same person every day, good day or bad.
2. Kind Heart
- I know what drives each person in my team and where they want to go.
- I protect one-on-ones and keep people in the loop, especially during change.
3. Wise Gut
- I make timely decisions without needing every fact first.
- I trust my people’s judgement and let go of the how.
4. Brave Spine
- I have the hard conversation within 48 hours, not 48 days.
- I own my mistakes out loud and hold everyone to the same standard, high performers included.
5. The Hands
- I spend more of my week serving my team than managing my image.
- Credit goes to my people. The misses are mine.
6. The Footprint
- If I left tomorrow, my team would be stronger for having worked with me.
- People who’ve worked for me go on to lead well themselves.
Attitude
- I actively ask for feedback on me, and I act on it.
- I’m still learning, still curious, and still a little bit hungry.
Reading your score
Add up each zone (out of 10).
- 9–10: That zone is a strength. Use it to lift others.
- 6–8: Solid, but it’ll wobble under pressure. Keep an eye on it.
- 5 or below: This is your starting point. Not a failure. A focus.
Now for the uncomfortable truth. We are all terrible judges of ourselves. What we think we’re doing and what our team actually experiences can be two very different movies. So if you really want to know where you stand, hand this list to your team and ask them to score you. Gulp. That’s exactly what the Human Leader Index™ 360 does, and trust me, it’s an eye-opener.
Pick your lowest zone. Just one. Work on it this week. Not next quarter. This week.
Because the world doesn’t need more bosses. It needs more human leaders. Go be one.
Over to you. What’s the worst thing you’ve ever seen a leader do? And what did it teach you? Tell me in the comments. I read every single one (yes, really).
Ready to do something about it?
Reading this is the easy bit. Doing something about it is where the magic happens. Here’s how I can help, depending on where you’re at.
Work with me
Want me in the room with your leaders? I deliver keynotes and executive coaching for leaders who are ready to stop playing it safe and start leading like humans. No fluff. No death by PowerPoint. Just the real, honest stuff that actually changes how people lead.
→ Book a keynote or a coaching chat at soniamcdonald.com or email sonia@soniamcdonald.com.au
LeadershipHQ: for your whole leadership team
If you read that list and pictured half your leadership team (go on, be honest), that’s where LeadershipHQ comes in. We’ve worked with more than 100 organisations on leadership programs, culture and the Human Leader Index™ 360. That’s the one that shows you what your team actually experiences, not what you’d like to think they experience.
Founding partner offer: we’re taking on just three organisations as Human Leader Index 360 founding partners. Places close 31 January 2027. When they’re gone, they’re gone.
→ Grab a spot at leadershiphq.com.au
